Capsules

Best K-Cup Pods and Variety Packs: Nine Boxes Compared

Nine popular K-Cup boxes on Amazon compared by roast, pack size and use: Peet's, Starbucks, Dunkin', McCafé, Donut Shop, Green Mountain, store brand, samplers.

Paid links: we may earn a commission from purchases.

For a dependable everyday mug, buy a 96-pod box of Starbucks Pike Place or McCafé Premium Roast. For the lowest cost per cup, Amazon's own Amazon Saver Dark Roast is the store-brand pick, typically well below the name brands per pod. For a darker, heavier cup, Peet's Major Dickason's. If you are new to Keurig and do not know what you like, start with Victor Allen's four-roast variety pack before committing to 96 of one coffee.

Product photographs: the brands shown.

Every pack below fits any current Keurig brewer. The real differences are roast level, how many pods you commit to and the price per pod, which matters more than the brewer price over a year: two mugs a day is roughly 730 pods. Prices move every week, so the cards show Amazon's current price for each box.

Starbucks Pike Place Roast

Roast
Medium
Pods
96 (4 × 24)
Best for
Familiar coffee-shop mug, hot or iced

McCafé Premium Roast

Roast
Medium
Pods
96 (4 × 24)
Best for
Mild, smooth everyday cup

The Original Donut Shop Regular

Roast
Medium
Pods
72
Best for
Coffee with milk

Dunkin' Original Blend

Roast
Medium
Pods
60 (6 × 10)
Best for
Trying a brand in small boxes

Green Mountain Breakfast Blend

Roast
Light
Pods
96 (4 × 24)
Best for
Brighter, less bitter black coffee

Peet's Major Dickason's Blend

Roast
Dark
Pods
75
Best for
Dark-roast drinkers

Amazon Saver Dark Roast (formerly Happy Belly)

Roast
Dark
Pods
100
Best for
Lowest cost per cup

Victor Allen's Core Roast Variety

Roast
Light to dark, 4 × 20
Pods
80
Best for
Finding your roast

Crazy Cups flavored sampler

Roast
Flavored, assorted
Pods
40
Best for
Flavored coffee

Pack sizes and roasts from the Amazon.com listings. The cards below show each box's current Amazon price.

US pod guide reviewed November 15, 2026. Pack sizes and roasts are Amazon.com listing data read through Amazon's product API that day; all nine packs were then sold by Amazon.com. We did not run a blind taste test. Prices change weekly and with Subscribe & Save, so each card shows Amazon's current price.

Everyday medium roasts: Starbucks, McCafé, Dunkin' and Donut Shop

These four are the default mugs of American coffee. Starbucks Pike Place is the most roasty of the group and is labeled for hot or iced brewing. McCafé Premium Roast is milder and smoother, the closest to a diner cup. Dunkin' Original Blend is made with arabica beans and comes in small boxes of ten, handy if you want to try it before a bigger order.

The Original Donut Shop is the one to choose if you add milk: it is sold as full-bodied and bold, so it stands up to cream better than McCafé. If you brew at 10 or 12 ounces, press the Strong button where your brewer has one; any medium roast tastes thin at the largest size.

WhichCapsule note: Cards: the exact packs listed in the table, with Amazon's current price.

Lighter or darker: Green Mountain and Peet's

Green Mountain Breakfast Blend is the light roast here, with toasted-nut and cocoa notes on the box. It suits people who find Starbucks too bitter, and it is a good morning coffee black. Expect a brighter, thinner cup than the medium roasts.

Peet's Major Dickason's is the heaviest, darkest pod of the nine and usually one of the pricier boxes per pod. It is the pick for people who usually drink French-press or dark coffee-shop coffee and find most K-Cups weak. Brew it at 8 ounces rather than 12 to keep its body.

WhichCapsule note: Cards: Green Mountain Breakfast Blend 96-count and Peet's Major Dickason's 75-count.

Lowest cost per cup: Amazon Saver Dark Roast

Amazon's store-brand dark roast comes in 100-pod boxes and is typically the cheapest pod per cup on this list, often around half the price of Starbucks or Peet's per pod. Over a year of daily mugs that difference adds up to more than many brewers cost. The pack is labeled as compatible with K-Cup brewers rather than as an official K-Cup, which matters only on old Keurig 2.0 machines; current brewers accept compatible pods.

If price per cup is the main reason you are on Keurig, this is the pack to put on Subscribe & Save. If it tastes flat to you, a name-brand medium roast is the next step up.

WhichCapsule note: Card: Amazon Saver Dark Roast, 100 pods.

View this model

Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.

Variety packs to find your coffee

Victor Allen's Core Roast Variety has 20 pods each of four roasts, light through dark, all 100% arabica and roasted in the US. It is the most sensible first order for a new brewer: within a few weeks you know whether you lean light or dark, and then you can buy a 96-count of a similar coffee.

The Crazy Cups sampler is 40 assorted flavored coffees. Buy it if you like flavored coffee or want to find one flavor worth buying in bulk; skip it if you drink your coffee black and unflavored.

WhichCapsule note: Cards: Victor Allen's 80-count variety pack and the Crazy Cups 40-count flavored sampler.

What people actually ask

What is the cheapest K-Cup per pod?

Store brands in 100-pod boxes, such as Amazon Saver Dark Roast, are usually the cheapest per pod. Variety packs like Victor Allen's are typically next. Check the current price on each card, since pod prices change weekly.

Do compatible pods work in a Keurig?

Yes in current Keurig brewers. Some older Keurig 2.0 machines only accept pods with the Keurig logo, so check your model if it dates from around 2014–2016.

Which K-Cup tastes most like coffee-shop coffee?

Peet's Major Dickason's for a dark cup and Starbucks Pike Place for a medium one. Brew either at 8 ounces, or use the Strong button, for a fuller mug.

Are K-Cup pods recyclable?

Keurig says its US K-Cups are recyclable after you peel off the lid and empty the grounds, but acceptance depends on your local program. In Canada, the Competition Bureau fined Keurig in 2022 for overstating how widely pods are accepted.

Which pack to buy

  • New to Keurig: Victor Allen's variety pack, then a 96-count of the roast you liked.
  • Everyday mug with milk: The Original Donut Shop; black: Starbucks Pike Place or McCafé.
  • Lowest cost per cup: Amazon Saver Dark Roast.
  • Dark-coffee drinker: Peet's Major Dickason's.
  • Still choosing a brewer: see Keurig K-Mini vs K-Express and Keurig K-Elite vs Nespresso VertuoPlus.

The bottom line

I would start with the Victor Allen's variety pack and a box of Starbucks Pike Place, then settle on one 96-count for Subscribe & Save. If cost is the point of owning a Keurig, the Amazon Saver dark roast is the box to compare first.

Choose your buying option

Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.

Keep exploring

View all guides