Comparisons

Vertuo Up vs Vertuo Creatista: Is the Steam Wand Worth It?

Vertuo Up vs Vertuo Creatista: a compact machine with an Aeroccino or an automatic steam wand, 47 oz vs 67 oz tank, size, iced coffee and who should pay more.

Paid links: we may earn a commission from purchases.

Buy the Vertuo Up if you mostly drink black or iced coffee and want a small machine, adding an Aeroccino for the occasional latte. Buy the Vertuo Creatista if you make milk drinks every day and want to texture the milk yourself, with control over temperature and foam, and you have room for one of the largest Vertuo machines.

Both brew every Vertuo size, from espresso to the 18 oz carafe, from the same barcode recipes, so black coffee tastes the same on either. The Creatista's extra price buys an automatic steam wand with a steel jug, three temperatures and three textures, and a 67 oz tank. The Up's buys the smallest body, a 3-second start and an over-ice button. Both take Vertuo pods only.

Vertuo Up vs Vertuo Creatista: the specs that decide it

Milk

Vertuo Up
None built in; Aeroccino bundle (BNV650) or add one
Vertuo Creatista
Automatic steam wand with steel jug (about 16 oz)

Milk control

Vertuo Up
Aeroccino presets (hot foam, cold foam)
Vertuo Creatista
3 temperatures, 3 textures; you pour

Iced coffee

Vertuo Up
Over-ice button (Coffee Creations)
Vertuo Creatista
No over-ice mode

Cup sizes

Vertuo Up
Espresso to 12 oz Alto and 18 oz carafe
Vertuo Creatista
Espresso to 12 oz XL and 18 oz carafe

Water tank

Vertuo Up
47 oz (1.4 L), rotating
Vertuo Creatista
67 oz (2 L)

Mugs per fill (about)

Vertuo Up
6
Vertuo Creatista
8, or three carafes

Heat-up (manufacturer)

Vertuo Up
About 3 seconds
Vertuo Creatista
Check the listing; the wand needs its own heat-up

Size (W x D x H)

Vertuo Up
About 4.7 x 19.3 x 10 in with the tank behind
Vertuo Creatista
About 9 x 16.4 x 12.6 in

Built by

Vertuo Up
Breville (BNV620) or De'Longhi (ENV200W)
Vertuo Creatista
Breville

Manufacturer figures; they vary by market listing. Cup sizes follow the pod barcode on both machines.

Source: manufacturer specifications published by Nespresso, Breville and De'Longhi; figures can differ slightly by market and version.

Vertuo Up: who is it for?

The Up is for people whose cups are mostly black, iced or finished with a splash of cold milk. It heats in about 3 seconds, brews every current size, and its over-ice button makes a concentrated coffee to pour over ice. At about 4.7 inches wide with the tank behind and 10 inches tall, it fits almost anywhere.

With the Aeroccino bundle (BNV650) it handles a few lattes a week: the frother heats or cold-foams milk while the pod brews, and you pour. The Vertuo Up review covers model codes and bundles.

WhichCapsule note: Black or iced coffee, small kitchen, lattes now and then: the Up.

Vertuo Creatista: who is it for?

The Creatista is for people who care what the milk feels like. Fill the steel jug, choose one of three temperatures and three textures, and the wand heats and foams the milk on its own, stopping when it is done. Then you pour, which lets you make a thin flat white, a foamy cappuccino or try free-pour latte art.

It is also a big machine with a 67 oz tank, about eight mugs or three carafes per fill, so a household that drinks a lot of coffee refills it less often. Our Vertuo Creatista review covers it in detail.

WhichCapsule note: Daily lattes, want control and latte art: the Creatista.

View on Amazon

Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.

Steam wand or Aeroccino: how different is the milk?

An Aeroccino makes a fixed foam: hot and airy, hot and dense on some models, or cold. It is quick and needs no skill, but you cannot fine-tune the texture, and the foam is thicker than the silky milk used for latte art.

The Creatista's wand gives you three textures, from flat to foamy, and three temperatures, and the jug lets you pour with control. That is the difference between a good latte and one you can draw a heart on. If you never plan to pour art and like your foam thick, the Aeroccino is enough. Aeroccino 3 vs Aeroccino 4 explains the frother options.

WhichCapsule note: Like thick foam and speed: Aeroccino. Want silky milk and pouring control: the wand.

How much space does each need?

This is the starkest difference. The Up is one of the smallest Vertuo machines, about 4.7 in wide with the tank behind; the Creatista is about 9 in wide, 16.4 in deep and 12.6 in tall, and you need room in front of the wand for the jug.

Measure the space with the lid open and the jug in place before ordering. If your counter is tight, the Up plus an Aeroccino takes far less room even with the frother beside it. Best Nespresso machines for small kitchens lists the compact options.

WhichCapsule note: Tight counter: the Up.

Which is better for iced coffee?

The Up, for its over-ice button. It brews a shorter, stronger coffee for pouring over ice, so the drink is not watered down. Add an Aeroccino that froths cold milk and you can make iced lattes. Nespresso's manual says not to use that mode with ristretto, Alto, Cold Brew Style or Carafe Pour Over Style pods.

The Creatista's wand only steams hot milk. You can brew an espresso over ice by hand, but there is no dedicated mode and no cold foam.

WhichCapsule note: Iced coffee often: the Up.

What do the pods cost on each machine?

The pods are the same, so the monthly bill is too: two coffees a day is about 60 pods, or six sleeves of ten. Milk drinks add milk, not pods.

The real gap is the machine price. The Creatista is one of the most expensive Vertuo machines, and the Up with an Aeroccino usually costs a fraction of it. Compare both cards on the day, and see our Original vs Vertuo cost analysis for pod prices across systems.

WhichCapsule note: Same pods; the steam wand is what you pay extra for.

Is there a middle option?

Yes: the Vertuo Lattissima froths milk automatically from a carafe and brews into the cup at one touch, with no pouring or settings. It suits daily milk drinkers who want convenience rather than control. Vertuo Up vs Vertuo Lattissima and Vertuo Creatista vs Vertuo Lattissima compare it with both machines here.

If you are open to the Original system for a milk machine, Vertuo Creatista vs Creatista Plus covers the Original version, which has more temperature and texture settings.

WhichCapsule note: Daily milk but no interest in pouring: the Vertuo Lattissima.

View on Amazon

Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.

What people actually ask

Is the Vertuo Creatista worth it over the Vertuo Up?

Only if you make milk drinks most days and want control over the milk. For black or iced coffee, the Up does the same job in a much smaller body.

Does black coffee taste different on the two machines?

No. Both read the pod barcode and brew it with the same recipe.

Can the Vertuo Up make lattes?

With an Aeroccino, yes. The BNV650 bundle includes one, and you pour the foamed milk over the coffee.

Can I do latte art with an Aeroccino?

It is hard. The Aeroccino makes thick foam; latte art needs the silky texture a steam wand like the Creatista's produces.

Which has the bigger tank?

The Creatista, at 67 oz, against about 47 oz on the Up.

Do both brew the carafe?

Yes. Both brew the 18 oz carafe pods.

Which is easier to clean?

The Up. The Creatista's wand needs wiping and purging after each use, and the jug needs washing.

Is there a quick way to choose the right Nespresso machine?

Yes. WhichCapsule's free Find My Machine quiz asks seven questions about your drinks, milk, counter space and budget, then ranks the Vertuo Up, the Vertuo Creatista and the other Original and Vertuo machines with the reason for each match. Take the quiz.

Who should buy which one

  • Black coffee most days: Vertuo Up.
  • Iced coffee: Vertuo Up, for the over-ice button.
  • Lattes a few times a week: Vertuo Up with Aeroccino.
  • Daily lattes and interest in latte art: Vertuo Creatista.
  • Daily milk drinks at one touch: Vertuo Lattissima.
  • Small counter: Vertuo Up.
  • Big household, few refills: Vertuo Creatista, for the 67 oz tank.
Take the quiz ↑

The bottom line

If you want to pour silky milk and make café-style drinks every day, I would buy the Creatista: nothing else in the Vertuo range gives you a real steam wand. For most people, though, I would buy the Up, add an Aeroccino if lattes are occasional, and keep the difference in price and counter space.

Still deciding? The machine finder ranks machines by your answers, and the Nespresso machine comparison chart lists every model side by side.

Pods for this machine

Start with Vertuo pods

Vertuo machines take only Vertuo pods. A variety pack is usually the cheapest way to find the coffee you will reorder.

Ready to buy? Check today's Amazon prices

Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.

Keep exploring

View all guides