This is really a system choice. The Up is a Vertuo machine: it reads a barcode on each pod and brews sizes from a 1.35 oz espresso to an 18 oz carafe. The CitiZ is an Original machine: it brews a 1.35 oz espresso and a 3.7 oz lungo from Original capsules, with two buttons. Capsules do not cross over in either direction. Original vs Vertuo explains the systems in depth.
Vertuo Up vs CitiZ: the specs that decide it
System
- Vertuo Up
- Vertuo pods only
- CitiZ
- Original capsules, including compatible brands
Cup sizes
- Vertuo Up
- Espresso, double espresso, gran lungo, mug, 12 oz Alto, 18 oz carafe
- CitiZ
- Espresso 1.35 oz, lungo 3.7 oz
Iced coffee
- Vertuo Up
- Over-ice button (Coffee Creations)
- CitiZ
- No dedicated mode
Water tank
- Vertuo Up
- 47 oz (1.4 L), rotating
- CitiZ
- About 34 oz (1 L)
Per fill (about)
- Vertuo Up
- 6 mugs
- CitiZ
- 25 espressos or 9 lungos
Heat-up (manufacturer)
- Vertuo Up
- About 3 seconds
- CitiZ
- About 25 seconds
Used-pod container
- Vertuo Up
- About 18 espresso or 13 mug pods
- CitiZ
- 9 to 11 capsules, depending on market
Size (W x D x H)
- Vertuo Up
- About 4.7 x 19.3 x 10 in with the tank behind
- CitiZ
- About 5.1 x 14.6 x 10.9 in
Milk
- Vertuo Up
- None; BNV650 bundle adds an Aeroccino
- CitiZ
- None; CitiZ&Milk adds an Aeroccino
App connection
- Vertuo Up
- Nespresso app
- CitiZ
- None
Manufacturer figures; they vary slightly by market listing. Per-fill counts exclude rinse cycles.
Source: manufacturer specifications published by Nespresso, Breville and De'Longhi; figures can differ slightly by market and version.
Compare prices on Amazon
Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.
Vertuo Up: who is it for?
The Up is for American-style coffee drinkers. One button brews a 7.8 oz mug, a 12 oz Alto or an 18 oz carafe for two or three people, with a crema layer on top. It heats in about 3 seconds and has an over-ice button for iced coffee.
The trade-off is pod choice: Vertuo pods come from Nespresso, with a narrower range than Original capsules and no supermarket-brand alternatives. The Vertuo Up review covers model codes and bundles.
WhichCapsule note: Mugs, carafes, iced coffee: the Up.
CitiZ: who is it for?
The CitiZ is for espresso drinkers. It brews a 1.35 oz espresso or a 3.7 oz lungo, has a fold-down support for small cups, and its retro design suits an open counter. Its 34 oz tank holds about 25 espressos.
Original capsules are the big draw: Nespresso's own range plus compatible capsules from many coffee brands, often cheaper and easy to find in stores. The CitiZ review has the details.
WhichCapsule note: Espresso, lungo and the widest capsule choice: the CitiZ.
View on Amazon
Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.
Which makes the bigger cup?
The Up, by far. Its largest single cup is the 12 oz Alto, and the carafe pods make 18 oz. The CitiZ's largest is the 3.7 oz lungo. You can add hot water to a lungo for an Americano, but it is a different drink from a Vertuo mug.
If you drink one large coffee in a travel mug every morning, the CitiZ will frustrate you. If you drink two espressos a day, the Up's mug sizes will sit unused. The Vertuo pod sizes guide shows every Vertuo format.
WhichCapsule note: Large mugs: the Up. Short coffee: the CitiZ.
What do the pods cost per month on each machine?
The counting is the same: two coffees a day is about 60 pods a month, or six sleeves of ten. The difference is the price per pod. Vertuo pods come from Nespresso only, and the larger sizes usually cost more per pod. Original capsules have compatible alternatives that often cost less, alongside Nespresso's own.
If your coffee is mostly espresso, the CitiZ usually keeps the monthly bill lower. If your coffee is mostly mugs, compare the cost of one Vertuo mug pod with two Original capsules plus hot water. Our Original vs Vertuo cost analysis walks through it.
WhichCapsule note: Compatible capsules give the CitiZ the cheaper monthly bill for espresso.
Espresso quality: is there a difference?
They brew differently. Original machines push water through the capsule at high pressure, the classic espresso method, with a thinner crema. Vertuo machines spin the pod to extract it, which gives a thick, foamy crema and suits larger cups.
Espresso purists usually prefer the Original style; mug drinkers often like the Vertuo crema. Neither is wrong; it depends on what you are used to and what you add. A Vertuo espresso is still a short 1.35 oz shot.
WhichCapsule note: Classic espresso: Original. Big crema and large cups: Vertuo.
Size, refills and daily use
Both are compact. The Up is about 4.7 in wide with its tank behind and about 10 in tall; the CitiZ is about 5.1 in wide and 10.9 in tall. The Up holds more water and more used pods, and starts faster, about 3 seconds against 25.
The CitiZ is simpler: a lever, two buttons, no app. The Up connects to the Nespresso app for cup sizes, temperature and maintenance, though you never need it to brew. Both need descaling on the manual's schedule (descaling guide).
WhichCapsule note: Fewer refills and a faster start: the Up. Simple and classic: the CitiZ.
What about milk drinks?
Neither has a built-in milk system, and both are sold with an Aeroccino: the Up as the BNV650, the CitiZ as CitiZ&Milk. An espresso-based cappuccino or latte is more traditional on the CitiZ; the Up's over-ice brew plus a cold-foam frother is the better pairing for iced lattes.
CitiZ vs CitiZ&Milk covers the Original bundle, and Aeroccino 3 vs Aeroccino 4 explains which frother you get.
WhichCapsule note: Want a frother? Both come in Aeroccino bundles.
Compare on Amazon
Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.
What people actually ask
Can the CitiZ use Vertuo pods?
No. The CitiZ takes Original capsules only, and the Vertuo Up takes Vertuo pods only.
Which is better for espresso?
Most espresso drinkers prefer the CitiZ's Original-style extraction. The Up makes a Vertuo espresso with a thicker crema.
Which is better for a big mug of coffee?
The Vertuo Up. It brews mugs up to the 12 oz Alto and an 18 oz carafe; the CitiZ stops at a 3.7 oz lungo.
Are pods cheaper for the CitiZ?
Usually, because Original capsules have compatible alternatives from other brands. Vertuo pods come from Nespresso only.
Which heats up faster?
The Vertuo Up, in about 3 seconds against about 25 for the CitiZ.
Do they make iced coffee?
The Up has an over-ice button. On the CitiZ you brew an espresso over ice by hand.
Which is smaller?
They are close. The Up is narrower with the tank behind, the CitiZ slightly taller. Check the depth of your counter for the Up.
Is there a quick way to choose the right Nespresso machine?
Yes. WhichCapsule's free Find My Machine quiz asks seven questions about your drinks, milk, counter space and budget, then ranks the Vertuo Up, the CitiZ and the other Original and Vertuo machines with the reason for each match. Take the quiz.
Who should buy which one
- Mugs and travel mugs: Vertuo Up.
- Carafe for guests: Vertuo Up.
- Iced coffee: Vertuo Up.
- Espresso and lungo: CitiZ.
- Lowest pod cost: CitiZ, with compatible capsules.
- Retro look on an open counter: CitiZ.
- Espresso plus lattes: CitiZ&Milk.
- Still unsure about the system: read Original vs Vertuo.
The bottom line
If your coffee is a mug, I would buy the Vertuo Up: it brews the sizes you actually drink, starts fast and handles iced coffee. If your coffee is a short espresso, I would buy the CitiZ, which brews in the classic style and gives you far more capsule choice at a lower cost per cup.
Not sure? The machine finder asks about your drinks and ranks machines from both systems, and Essenza Mini vs CitiZ compares the CitiZ with the smallest Original machine.
View the picks on Amazon
Paid links. Prices can change; the price at checkout applies.











vs
vs
vs

